• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Navy removes USS Theodore Roosevelt captain

This means fewer port calls during the epidemic. Letting the crew have liberty in Vietnam should not have been allowed. But during my career a tenet of leadership was to take care of your men, maybe the USN doesn't teach that course.
 
As if being relieved isn't enough punishment the Navy may be looking at further punishment which to my thinking is some form of a letter of reprimand. The SECNAV is offering redemption a letter of reprimand might be hard to overcome. His rank is safe so all he need do is run out the clock until he can retire.
 
Very comprehensive article on the subject by the Daily Mail:

Fired captain of USS Theodore Roosevelt tests positive for coronavirus as it's revealed top US commanders 'were opposed to his dismissal but were OVERRULED by Navy secretary because Trump wanted him gone over letter'
- Acting Navy Secretary made decision to remove Capt. Brett Crozier on Thursday
- Crozier wrote letter to Navy high command about coronavirus on USS Roosevelt
- He demanded Navy evacuate aircraft carrier due to an outbreak on board
- Crozier's letter was eventually leaked to the news media on Monday
- Military chiefs initially began investigation into the leak of Crozier's letter
- But the acting secretary, Thomas Modly, decided to fire him immediately
- Modly is reported to have been told that the president wanted Crozier gone
- Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of Joint Chiefs of Staff, favored a military probe
- Top naval officer, Adm. Michael C. Gilday, also opposed immediate termination
- But they were overruled by Modly, who announced firing on Thursday
- Video online shows sailors giving rousing salute to Modly as he left ship in Guam
- So far, some 150 sailors who were on board Roosevelt have tested positive
...

See the whole article here: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8189285/Top-commanders-opposed-dismissing-captain-USS-Theodore-Roosevelt-coronavirus-letter.html

I find it interesting that Defence Secretary Esper, in defencing the Acting Secretary of the Navy's firing stating that "Only 155 of the 2,000 crewmen tested positive for coronavirus.

“We need to take care of the sailors on the ship. We need to ensure their well-being and get that ship back out to sea as soon as possible,” Mr. Esper said. “I’m pleased to report right now over half of the ship has been tested. Only 155 sailors have come up positive. Those are all mild to moderate. There have been no hospitalizations whatsoever. The crew is being taken care of out there.”
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2020/apr/5/uss-theodore-roosevelt-has-155-coronavirus-cases-m/

Faulty rationalization if I ever heard it. By any level of measurement, 155 infected out of 2,000 is a very high rate of infection and, considering the tight quarters on board ship, was well on it's way to becoming a disaster. With math like that amongst the senior leadership, I can readily see why this captain wrote that letter. It was his duty to do so.

:cheers:
 
7th Fleet Commander Arrives in Guam during COVID-19 Recovery
https://www.navy.mil/submit/display.asp?story_id=112554
Story Number: NNS200405-01Release Date: 4/5/2020 9:52:00
From Commander, U.S. 7th Fleet Public Affairs

APRA HARBOR, Guam (NNS) -- APRA HARBOR, Guam (NNS) – The Commander of U.S. 7th Fleet visited USS Theodore Roosevelt (CVN 71) leadership in port at Naval Base Guam while the aircraft carrier undergoes its COVID-19 recovery efforts April 5.

Vice Adm. Bill Merz, commander, U.S. 7th Fleet arrived on Guam to support the ongoing recovery effort on the Nimitz-class carrier, and he met with the crew and area leadership.

“The team in Guam has shown enormous spirit and focus getting this ship healthy again. Know that every day, regardless of what the challenge may be, my number one priority is to sustain the warfighting posture of 7th Fleet, and the most important element of this number one priority is the Sailors,” said Merz. “We simply cannot execute the mission of defending our interests, our friends, and our allies without the fighting spirit of the immensely capable men and women of this team. It takes a lot of cooperation and coordination, and although we have a lot of work to do I want to make sure those involved are getting our support and gratitude. The families of our Sailors should be proud of the ongoing efforts and know that we’re going to take care of our people.”

Vice Adm. Merz visited locations on Naval Base Guam, discussing logistics and the ship recovery process with counterparts from Joint Region Marianas, Carrier Strike Group Nine, and the Naval Base Guam commanding officer.

The ship arrived in Guam Mar. 27 for a scheduled port visit. Prior to the port visit three Sailors tested positive for COVID-19 aboard USS Theodore Roosevelt. The Navy has undertaken an aggressive mitigation plan that is currently isolating, quarantining, and treating affected Sailors to keep the ship prepared to execute its mission.

The Navy is working closely with the Government of Guam and Joint Region Marianas to follow U.S. Centers for Disease Control (CDC) guidelines to move Sailors safely off ship while continuing to maintain the vessel’s readiness to operate at sea.

"Theodore Roosevelt Strike Group is extremely thankful for the overwhelming support from the government of Guam and Naval Base Guam in the fight against COVID-19," said Rear Adm. Stu Baker, commander, Carrier Strike Group Nine. "Even with such short notice, they were able to assist getting our Sailors moved off ship in a short period of time. Their support has been critical to our ability to remain mission ready.”

Sailors from Theodore Roosevelt will be using various hotels across the island, allowing them to align with the recommended 14-day quarantine period while also maintaining an all hands effort aboard to sanitize the ship. The all hands effort though does not rest solely with the Roosevelt, but with all who are helping its Sailors get well and back to sea.

"The Joint Region Marianas and Naval Base Guam teams have moved mountains to help our TR shipmates get healthy and back out to sea," said Rear Adm. John Menoni, commander, Joint Region Marianas. "I can't say enough how proud I am of everyone's hard work during this very dynamic situation. Our partners in the Government and the people of Guam have helped us from day one and we are thankful for their assistance helping the TR Team be ready to fight.”

U.S. 7th Fleet provides security alongside allies and partners throughout a free and open Indo-Pacific. As the U.S. Navy's largest forward-deployed fleet, 7th Fleet operates roughly 50-70 ships and submarines and 140 aircraft with approximately 20,000 Sailors.


In the accompanying photos while some of the captions do mention the TR, none show or identify the new (temporary?) CO of the ship that is at the centre of  this story.  https://www.navy.mil/list_all.asp?id=112554

Any bets on how long he lasts?
 
[size=12pt]Fired Theodore Roosevelt skipper tests positive for COVID-19[/size]
Capt. Brett Crozier, hailed by his crew but fired as skipper of the aircraft carrier Theodore Roosevelt by Navy leadership following a leaked bombshell letter, has tested positive for COVID-19, the New York Times first reported.

The paper cited two Naval Academy classmates of Crozier’s who are close to him and his family.

A Navy spokesman declined to comment to the Times on Crozier’s COVID-19 status. Navy officials could not immediately respond to questions from Navy Times about Crozier’s health status or the New York Times report. The commander began exhibiting symptoms before he was removed from the warship on Thursday, two of his classmates said.
...
If true, definitely not the last of that crew who is still going to test positive, notwithstanding the assertion they were being "well taken care of" by Esper.
 
Just seeing on CNN the ousted Capt. has been found infected with COVID-19.
 
X Royal said:
Just seeing on CNN the ousted Capt. has been found infected with COVID-19.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/navy-captain-removed-from-carrier-tests-positive-for-covid-19/ar-BB12c4ip?ocid=spartanntp&pfr=1
 
Navy_Pete said:
His proposal was basically to go down to minimum crew required and get everyone else ashore in quarantine for a few weeks while the ship was being cleaned. That would have included whoever is required to look after the reactor.  From my really basic understanding, don't think reactors get shut down, but can get basically turned down to a minimum.
Certainly; I was thinking of the situation if he'd shut up and continued with normal business, leaving a ship unable to go to minimum manning in any useful way.
 
Acting Navy secretary blasts ousted aircraft carrier captain as 'stupid' in address to ship's crew

"If he didn't think, in my opinion, that this information wasn't going to get out to the public, in this day and information age that we live in, then he was either A, too naïve or too stupid to be a commanding officer of a ship like this," Modly said. "The alternative is that he did this on purpose."

Modly went on to say it was a "betrayal of trust, with me, with his chain of command."

...

Modly's use of the word "betrayal" is a loaded because saying an officer has betrayed the Navy is a court martial offense.

https://www.cnn.com/2020/04/06/politics/uss-tr-crozier-modly/index.html
 
A well written commentary about this in War on the Rocks.  Worth the read.

THE NAVY’S CRISIS OF SPECIAL TRUST AND CONFIDENCE
https://warontherocks.com/2020/04/the-navys-crisis-of-special-trust-and-confidence/
 
"If he didn't think, in my opinion, that this information wasn't going to get out to the public, in this day and information age that we live in, then he was either A, too naïve or too stupid to be a commanding officer of a ship like this," Modly said. "The alternative is that he did this on purpose."

Usually after "either A" comes "or B". -- Unless of course you're too naïve or too stupid to use the English language properly (although some may question whether "either A ... or B ..." is proper use in the first place). Regardless, Modly sounds like a real self serving, rationalizing d*ck. This was in an address to the crew who had previously applauded Crozier. He went on to say:

... "I cannot control or attempt to change whatever anger you have with me for relieving your beloved CO," Modly said, using the slang for commanding officer. "I understand you may be angry with me for the rest of your lives."

Modly also chastised the Theodore Roosevelt’s crew for cheering Crozier when he left the ship, claiming the former commanding officer’s memo caused concern among residents of Guam, where the ship is currently docked.

“So think about that when you cheer the man of the ship who exposed you to that,” Moldy said. “I understand you love the guy. It's good that you love him. But you're not required to love him.”

"Crew of the Teddy Roosevelt, you are under no obligation to love your leadership, only respect it," he continued. "You are under no obligation to like your job, only to do it. You are under no obligation, you are under no obligation to expect anything from your leaders other than they will treat you fairly and put the mission of the ship first."

The acting navy secretary took aim at the Theodore Roosevelt’s crew, telling them their only concern right now should be how they can help each other during the crisis.

“That's your duty,” Modly said. “Not to complain. Everyone is scared about this thing. And let me tell ya something, if this ship was in combat and there were hypersonic missiles coming in at it, you'd be pretty fucking scared too. But you do your jobs. And that's what I expect you to. And that's what I expect every officer on this ship to do, is to do your jobs.”

https://taskandpurpose.com/news/navy-secretary-blasts-fired-aircraft-carrier-captain

This too will go down in the annals of naval history as a wonderful example of how to re-instil morale. Not.

There are now 173 crew members testing positive with 61% tested.


:cheers:
 
Well this is going to be a remarkable case study on leadership in the face of disease borne challenges. Now we wait and see if another Captain fails to act because of this and their ship is incapacitated by sickness. I can imagine the same issues are hitting the PLAN, but without the public exposure. it will be interesting to see how their sailing schedule and operational patterns have been effected and will be. 
 
Holy sh*t, he made that address over the main broadcast (ie the public address system).  What a wanker.

The recording is pretty funny though; I think we are all the sailor that dropped the 'WTF?' when he said the CO was too naive or stupid. That kind of silence is a really, really bad sign. Normally there is some banter and chatter; this feels like they were sharpening their knives and looking for a convenient spot to practice a man overboard exercise (poorly).  Also the whole speech is about what happens when things get out to the media, and then the speech gets uploaded to soundcloud.

I don't understand this logic at all; there was really no reason for him to drop this on the crew, and he just crippled the ability of the acting CO to get this crew refocused and back on mission.

Brutal. This is the opposite of leadership.
 
Navy_Pete said:
Holy sh*t, he made that address over the main broadcast (ie the public address system).  What a wanker.

The recording is pretty funny though; I think we are all the sailor that dropped the 'WTF?' when he said the CO was too naive or stupid. That kind of silence is a really, really bad sign. Normally there is some banter and chatter; this feels like they were sharpening their knives and looking for a convenient spot to practice a man overboard exercise (poorly).  Also the whole speech is about what happens when things get out to the media, and then the speech gets uploaded to soundcloud.

I don't understand this logic at all; there was really no reason for him to drop this on the crew, and he just crippled the ability of the acting CO to get this crew refocused and back on mission.

Brutal. This is the opposite of leadership.

Even the language is brutal.  Someone in Modly's position should not be swearing on an address to the crew.  It's like he's *trying* to make the situation worse.
 
I'll just quote Modly here about the outcome of his speech...

If he didn't think, in my opinion, that this information wasn't going to get out into the public, in this day and information age that we live in, then he was either A, too naive, or too stupid
 
Dimsum said:
Someone in Modly's position should not be swearing on an address to the crew.

Modly, an 1983 graduate of the USNA and a former Naval aviator, was probably trying to give his best impression of a tough-talking "commander", you know, just like the president who appointed him tries to do.
 
Blackadder1916 said:
Modly, an 1983 graduate of the USNA and a former Naval aviator, was probably trying to give his best impression of a tough-talking "commander", you know, just like the president who appointed him tries to do.

Helicopters for a few years before he went into private industry. Crozier started helicopters then went F18s. Probably some professional jealousy (p*n*s envy) there on Modly's part.  ;D

:cheers:
 
I did get a laugh picturing his protective detail as his speech went on though; seems like the kind of speech where it would just take one hothead to get a crowd to get pokey-chest, and would end badly for SecNav, and had a mental image of those poor folks getting increasingly ready to carry his arse off the ship at a run.
 
...and the Acting SECNAV has now apologized for his remarks.  I guess he didn't stand by every word he said.

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Acting U.S. Navy Secretary Thomas Modly issued an apology on Monday to the former commander of a coronavirus-stricken aircraft carrier after sharply criticizing him in a speech to his crew, just days after firing him.

“I do not think Captain Brett Crozier is naive nor stupid,” Modly said amid calls for his removal, including from the chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, a Democrat.

The apology, which Modly also extended to the carrier’s crew and Crozier’s family, was a reversal from a statement the Navy’s top civilian issued hours earlier that said: “I stand by every word I said.”

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-usa-navy-apology-idUSKBN21P03N?utm_source=reddit.com
 
Back
Top