Extremely interesting thread!
I agree with geo on the subject of what we would do with all of those conscripts if we ever had them. The slackers of today, who volunteered, are able to figure out and use the system to avoid work and undesireable (to them) training at will, sometimes before even finishing QL3. I shudder to think how a conscript army could paralyze some of our services with people trying to ride out their year or two on a chit for "sore feet".
Armyvern, before you wax poetic about "the good ol' days" lets not forget that if we go too far back, you (as a woman) would not be permitted to join as anything but a medic or clerk, and later, could be kicked out for being pregnant. Soldiers were often poorly educated, alchol abuse was rampant, and the military was often viewed by the rest of society as an "employer of last resort" It was'nt all good!
I also find it interesting that no-one has mentioned the conscription crises that nearly tore this country apart in the past. Quebeckers have, in the past, violently opposed conscription to fight in "English wars". I would guess that this would also be the case today.
We should institute a draft if we need it, to defend the nation and her vital interests. We don't need to now, so let's stockpile the old kit, and train up a new army if we need to.