The show in itself doesn't have a smooth flow, lacks a sort of realism that was seen in Band of Brothers...something very made-in-your-own-back-yard about it. Dialogue seems almost forced and not so well timed... No matter what...there's going to be people who love it, people who hate it, people who'll be severely against it, people who will try to profit from making a show about a war, while the war itself is still being fought. Personally, I think theres should be a pre-warning to the parental guidance warning that reads something like "This show is for entertainment purposes only. It is not based on the views or opinions of service members and reflects no facts or actual events that have taken place."
I guess I'm just a fan of shows based on fact...like Band of Brothers. I might be bias, but I don't think anything will surpass Band of Brothers (not yet anyways...unless Tom Hanks and Steven Spielberg team up once again)