- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 110
SPM said:
Pun alert
Congratulations by the way.
Pun alert
Congratulations by the way.
Trumpeter42
Guest
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 60
I thought I would post a follow-up to my original post in 2010. At that time, I did a second hearing test with an audiologist and was able to squeak by with an H3 rating. So my transfer was successful.
Since then, my career has progressed and I'm now preparing for my next (final) career promotion. Sure enough, at my age, my medical expires every 2 years so I'm going to have to do it again. It's also difficult to do the annual Force test without a current medical. I've been aggressively trying to protect my hearing since 2010... Custom earplugs in use anywhere there is loud noise, concerts, movies, gun firing, etc. Somehow, I still feel my hearing is still not what it was 3 years ago.
Keeping my fingers crossed again....
Since then, my career has progressed and I'm now preparing for my next (final) career promotion. Sure enough, at my age, my medical expires every 2 years so I'm going to have to do it again. It's also difficult to do the annual Force test without a current medical. I've been aggressively trying to protect my hearing since 2010... Custom earplugs in use anywhere there is loud noise, concerts, movies, gun firing, etc. Somehow, I still feel my hearing is still not what it was 3 years ago.
Keeping my fingers crossed again....
- Reaction score
- 2
- Points
- 230
Spartan80 said:
Not sure why this is such a hard thing to understand. You may *feel* you are capable of doing the job, but ultimately the CAF has deemed otherwise. I have a friend who's dream was to be in the military - he is also profoundly deaf. Could he do some tasks? Yes. Can he meet the minimum requirements of the CAF? No. What did you hope to appeal?
I'm not sure, I understand everything is based on how I'd do but I wouldn't just want to give it up just like that. that is all, I feel as if I am required to try, the medical officer told me I could still apply even after being told what he told me... why would he say that?
- Reaction score
- 2
- Points
- 230
Spartan80 said:
No idea, you'd have to ask him.
Let me give you an example of how being deaf in one year is be an issue. Radios are often set up to have different "nets" into a single headset, one in each ear. - while deployed in the field I listen to two separate radio communications at the same time. Might be a bit of an issue if I have no idea my boss is talking to me while I am talking to others, no?
If you haven't been told your application will not be processed, by all means give it a try. When you say things like "appeal" it implies you have already have been given a final answer. While it may not be easily understood, the minimum standards typically exist for a good reason.
- Reaction score
- 2
- Points
- 230
There are obviously some details left out here. I'm assuming you went into a CFRC with the following details about your hearing stated up front and were told that you wouldn't meet the requirements. My assumption (you'd need to fill in some details here) is that he is telling you, in his professional opinion, that an application would not meet the minimum requirements due to this fact. You aren't prevented from applying, but you are highly likely (read almost certainly) to get the same response when your application makes it to the medical.
There is nothing to appeal until your application is denied. Not that I am advocating that route however.
There is nothing to appeal until your application is denied. Not that I am advocating that route however.
- Reaction score
- 234
- Points
- 680
He told you that because the system is not allowed to stop you from applying. Once you do apply, then the appropriate part of the system (in this case medical) will assess you and then tell you that you don't meet the minimum required standard.
What should you do? IMO you should not bother applying as all you will do is create more work for no gain. Sorry you can't be in the CAF. If you still want to give back to society, there are plenty of other ways. Volunteer or join a service organization that doesn't have as strict standards as the CAF.
My two cents worth. Take it or leave it.
What should you do? IMO you should not bother applying as all you will do is create more work for no gain. Sorry you can't be in the CAF. If you still want to give back to society, there are plenty of other ways. Volunteer or join a service organization that doesn't have as strict standards as the CAF.
My two cents worth. Take it or leave it.
I went and wrote my CFAT, but with my hearing being a big concern with my chance of success I had faxed over a copy of my most recent audio gram and a Sgt in the medical office had looked at it and called me back. I have within normal hearing in the left ear and no hearing in the right. so I decided to ask.What do you suggest I do in the route of giving back to the service members who have given their all to me? Also I truly do appreciate all the help I am getting, this really does bug me as I am unsure as what to do as a career now
Ayrsayle said:
Spartan80 said:
Since you already know the outcome, how about not wasting resources in the recruiting system? I appreciate that you're disappointed, but you're not going to receive some sort of special waiver that gets you past basic medical requirements.
medicineman
Army.ca Legend
- Reaction score
- 5,722
- Points
- 1,110
Dude - I get that you're upset, but the fact is that you require binaural hearing and binocular vision to be enrolled. That's it. That's all. You aren't the first to be told and I'm sure you won't be the last. You can appeal if you like, it's your right, however suffice to say this - it's been challenged in court many a time and the SCC has upheld that CAF is still allowed to discriminate based on disabilities due to the potential and actual nature of employment. Lots of people (even some doctors that have entertained me with claims about their patients) with ZERO military experience feel that they can do the job - we do/did the job and know what it entails and why the standards are what they are.
Honestly I'm sorry you got the "Dear John" letter. I hope the next path that appears is right for you.
MM
Honestly I'm sorry you got the "Dear John" letter. I hope the next path that appears is right for you.
MM
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 210
Spartan80 said:
Since I know SPM in real life, I am prevvy to everything he did to be successful in the application process.
Basically he went to a hearing specialist that did a sound test, showed the doctor the hearing standards for the CAF, and then the doctor wrote a lil something up saying he was within those standards. Afterwards he wrote up a nice appeal, submitted it, and later won.
Now.. something he did have to do in October before getting a while back was do another medical since it had been a year... and according to him the people that did his medical before screwed it all up.. cause he was actually within the standard to begin with.
So... that's what you got to do.
And this...
SPM said:
Amazing.. job offer soon.. hah... we were so impatient lol. Although he did get a job offer in march.. for the wrong occupation.
- Reaction score
- 2
- Points
- 230
Spartan80 said:
Cadet Instructors Cadre.
They have basically one requirement: you can't be a sexual predator.
- Reaction score
- 1,288
- Points
- 940
Spartan80 said:
It seems that he's advising you to appeal the decision, however, IMO since you are deaf in one ear, your case is completely different than that of SPM (who Treemoss quoted).
I tend to agree with this comment:
Harris said:
Similar threads
